You may be surprised to hear, that even when people who are going through a divorce or separation, have come to an agreement in relation to their property and financial matters – there is no automatic right that the Court will accept this agreement. Sometimes, the Court will reject the proposed agreement and will then proceed to make decision and determinations of the issues, whether you agree or not.
Doesn’t really sound very fair? Or does it?
On 7 March 2018, in the case of Silva and Phoenix, this is exactly what happened. Here are the facts:
So when can a Judge be disqualified ?
When a Judge shows an actual or an appearance of bias and has pre-decided a case.
In this instance, the Court of Appeal found in favour of the Husband and made orders that disqualified the Judge.
The Court of Appeal said that not only was there an appearance of bias ( apprehended bias) but the Judge’s knowledge of what the Husband was prepared to offer the Wife ( i.e. his ‘compromised’) position was known to the Judge and where the Judge said that 10% was not a just and equitable adjustment of the assets and he was of the view that the Wife ought to receive more – this was clearly a case where the Judge had pre-judged the case and had shown bias.
The point of the case of Silva and Phoenix is this- even when you and your ex-partner come to an agreement regarding either parenting or property matters – the Court can reject the agreement if it doesn’t believe that the Orders are in the case of children in their best interests or just and equitable in the case of property matters !
Unfortunately it can then raise the issue of a Judge being biased against one side- if this happens, then there are obviously more delays, more costs and the matter takes longer to finalise.
Disclaimer: The information herein is not intended as legal advice- it is legal information of a very general nature. Where you have a family law matter and require specialist family law advice or representation, please contact us on 02 8999 1800 or email@example.com
Are you separated? Have you tried everything to end your property matters with your ex? No matter how hard you negotiate …
In child custody matters, taking a child out of the state without the other parent’s consent can pose several complex legal …
Sadly, sometimes one parent will refuse to co-parent with the other parent when a marriage, same-sex or de facto relationship ends …